Here's what's actually happening at a lot of these brokerages. They're growing agent count, which logically should mean more transactions — but here's the part nobody talks about. Every agent you bring on has a cost. Onboarding, training, the tech stack you're providing, the splits you're offering to stay competitive. If you're not careful, by the time you add all that up, you're basically breaking even on that agent — or worse, you're in the red on them for the first year. That's fine if you have a plan for how that agent becomes profitable. Most brokerages don't. They just keep recruiting.
"The top line goes up. The agent count goes up. And the owner is scratching their head wondering why it doesn't feel like a business."
Most brokerages are operating on margins that would make any other business owner uncomfortable — anywhere from 3% to maybe 15% net, if you're being honest. A huge chunk of that lives or dies based on splits. And I'm not saying pay your agents less — that's not the point. The point is: do you actually know what your margin looks like per agent, individually? Because some agents at your brokerage are profitable, some are break-even, and some — if you ran the real numbers — are actually costing you money.
The almost-never-discussed truth is that it's not about the split. It's about production. An agent on a 70/30 split doing 20 transactions a year is infinitely more valuable than one on a 90/10 doing 4. Everyone talks about how competitive their splits are — but splits are a cost, and production is what creates that cost. That's the math.
So what should you actually be tracking? Net revenue per agent — not gross, not after-split, after-expenses, after-everything. Your cost to carry a low-producing agent: desk fees, tech, your time managing them. That number is almost always higher than people expect. And the one that gets underrated most — what does it cost you when a great agent leaves? You don't just lose their transactions. You lose the referral network they were building, you lose culture, and then you spend money recruiting someone new to replace them.
"Retention is a margin conversation. A hundred percent."
Keeping a great agent is almost always cheaper than replacing them, but most brokerages don't think about it that way because retention doesn't show up as a line item. The shift that changes everything is simple: stop thinking about your brokerage as a headcount game. Know your margins, know your numbers per agent, know what's actually costing you. The brokerages that figure this out aren't just growing — they're building something that lasts. The ones who don't will have a great story to tell on the next industry list. Right up until they don't.
If you're looking to grow your brokerage, increase deal flow, and build a more resilient business, explore more insights at joekillinger.co, subscribe to the newsletter, or connect directly to start the conversation.
